Thought Archive

Fringe in Power: When Conspiracy Becomes Policy

11 Sept 2025

Fringe in Power: When Conspiracy Becomes Policy

Hook

The lunatics used to be outside the palace walls, shouting about fluoride, chemtrails, or “reds under the bed.”
Now they’re inside, signing decrees, leading hearings, and ordering reports.

What happens when conspiracy becomes not just a distraction but the governing logic?

Context

Take Robert F. Kennedy Jr. — now U.S. Health Secretary — telling the Senate that kids get up to 92 vaccine doses. Or teasing a national autism report that could link Tylenol to developmental disorders.
It sounds like the stuff of late-night talk radio. But this isn’t the fringe anymore; it’s policy in formation.

He’s not alone. Across the globe, leaders are riding the same wave:

  • Populists in Europe talk openly about “shadowy cabals.”
  • Ex-presidents in the U.S. still question elections they lost.
  • Authoritarians in Asia and Africa blame invisible enemies for every setback.

The internet didn’t just supercharge conspiracy theories — it normalized them. And in politics, normalization is power.

Your Take

Here’s the uncomfortable truth: madness is not a bug, it’s a strategy.

  • Paranoia mobilizes. Nothing builds loyalty faster than a shared sense of threat.
  • Chaos dominates attention. The more outrageous the claim, the more oxygen it steals from calm, careful voices.
  • Suspicion inoculates leaders. If you’ve convinced your followers that everyone is corrupt, then your own scandals slide off.

RFK Jr. isn’t just “wrong on the numbers.” He’s demonstrating a wrecking-ball playbook:

  1. Undermine trust in institutions. Suggest they’re lying, captured, or hiding the truth.
  2. Amplify uncertainty. Take a kernel of science (e.g., Harvard Tylenol study) and stretch it into existential doubt.
  3. Offer yourself as the reformer. If the system is rotten, who better than the outsider-insider to rebuild it?

It’s not insanity — it’s insurgency by rhetoric.

Implications

Where does this end? That’s the real paranoia worth having.

We’re staring at two possible futures:

  1. Fragmented reality.
    Each tribe spins off into its own epistemic bubble. Facts don’t cross borders. Trust in media, science, and law collapses. Public health, climate response, even basic governance become impossible.

  2. Painful reset.
    Historically, chaos invites correction — but only after the damage. Think Great Depression before FDR, or McCarthyism before the backlash. Crises force people to demand sober leadership again. But by then, the wreckage is already baked in.

Either way, the middle ground — where institutions quietly did their job and the fringes ranted on the sidelines — feels gone.

The Deeper Issue

It’s tempting to say, “Well, the crazies just got lucky.” But that misses the structural truth: our systems now reward the outrageous.

  • Social media algorithms elevate anger, not nuance.
  • News cycles crave conflict, not clarity.
  • Voters, exhausted and cynical, gravitate to the candidate who at least sounds like they see through the lies.

We don’t have a crisis of sanity. We have a crisis of incentives.

And here’s the kicker: those same leaders plunging us into paranoia are also plunging us into debt. They’re running up historic deficits while preaching about betrayal and corruption. Fiscal responsibility disappears under the weight of slogans.

And if paranoia is their compass, what stops them from stumbling into war on a whim? Leaders who thrive on chaos are exactly the kind who might escalate a border clash or proxy conflict overnight — with millions paying the price.

Further Reading

Closing

The question isn’t just whether the fringe has entered the palace — it’s what they’ll do with the keys. These are the same people writing trillion-dollar IOUs and wielding armies that could be unleashed on a whim.

We can’t keep laughing off the fever dreams as political theater. Paranoia in power means debt without end, wars without warning, and futures mortgaged on conspiracy.

It’s time to wake up — because the cost of sleeping through this isn’t abstract. It’s measured in bankruptcies, body bags, and broken generations.